14 Best Shelter Island San Diego Hotels and Other Nearby Options

Shelter Island sometimes feels like one of San Diego’s secret hideaways. Built in the 1950s, this manmade peninsula is connected to the Point Loma community on the mainland.

Surrounded by eleven acres of lush tropical gardens, the hotel provides complimentary cruiser bikes to tour around the property.


Reminiscent of a contemporary tropical retreat, guestrooms, and deluxe suites feature tasteful island-style décor, including custom headboards.

Humphreys Half Moon Inn

This incredible seaside location is ideal for families who want to spend their days exploring. The hotel offers bike rentals and a variety of sailing and boat trips.

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Offering a selection of  well-appointed nautical-inspired guest rooms and suites, you can relax in style.


With its mid-century design and modern amenities, is located in the heart of Point Loma and offers 23 sustainably-minded rooms with local ceramics and original and vintage artwork.

The Pearl Hotel

You’ll find Portuguese-inspired decor — a nod to the area’s Portuguese community — mixed with mid-century modern.

The Monsaraz San Diego, Tapestry Collection by Hilton

Swipe up to learn more!