How to Make Easy Harry Potter Chocolate Frogs Like Honeydukes at Universal

Harry Potter fans are familiar with the popularity of chocolate frogs in the wizarding world. These candy frogs come to life, hopping out of boxes before being eaten. Harry, Ron, and other Hogwarts friends often trade the collectible wizard cards inside each chocolate frog box. But you don’t have to go to Honeydukes at Universal Studios to get these treats (though that would be a lot more fun).

Making Harry Potter chocolate frogs at home for a Harry Potter party or gathering (including the cards and boxes) is actually very easy. Here is how you do it.

See also: How to Plan the Ultimate Harry Potter London Vacation

Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. If you make purchases through them, we may be compensated. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you for supporting our small business. See our editorial guidelines.

How to Make Harry Potter Chocolate Frogs

For Harry Potter chocolate frogs, you will need:

• a frog mold
• good chocolate that melts well (Merckens)
• or, perhaps a Harry Potter chocolate frog kit that also has fudge fly molds

That’s seriously it. I was surprised that I could actually make these in a matter of minutes.

I melted the chocolate in a double boiler, which I highly recommend if you have one. Within minutes, I could stir the chocolate to a consistency with absolutely zero lumps. This doesn’t happen as easily with grocery store chocolate chips, trust me. It’s not our first time making candy in molds, and I will definitely only use Merckens chocolate going forward. One 2-lb bag made about 24 chocolate frogs using this mold.

I took a small gravy spoon and filled each frog mold to the top. A few taps of the tray on the counter released bubbles inside the chocolate. The chocolate frogs were then chilled in the refrigerator for 10-20 minutes. When they fall out of the mold without effort, you know they’re done. There was no banging the mold or prying them out. They released with zero effort.

You don’t have to really worry about being tidy when pouring the chocolate into the chocolate frog molds. I used my fingernail to simply flick extra chocolate off the frog. The heat of from my finger smoothed down any rough edges. I have a little Wilton decorating brush that I swept any loose flakes off the frog. It helps but isn’t mandatory.

Harry Potter Chocolate Frog Cards

Making the chocolate frog cards was a snap, too. I downloaded chocolate frog card PDFs from Etsy featuring Godric Gryffindor, Helga Hufflepuff, Rowena Ravenclaw, Salazar Slytherin, and Albus Dumbledore. There is also a blank card where you can place your photo, perhaps a birthday boy or girl if the occasion is a birthday party. Search Etsy to find them.

I agree with the Etsy seller’s recommendation to print these on glossy photo paper. The cards are double-sided and best secured with double-sided tape. Easy.

Harry Potter Chocolate Frog Box

The chocolate frog box should also be printed on glossy photo paper or at least cardstock paper that is thick enough to fold up properly. I tried both and think that glossy photo paper looks best. You can download replica chocolate frog boxes from Etsy in PDF form, print them, cut out the box, and fold them into shape. The one I originally bought isn’t listed anymore.

The directions suggested securing the box with double-sided tape, which works (and is easiest for) the top of the box. However, I found that using a glue gun held up better for the bottom of the box.

Tip: Plan to fold a few boxes first to get the hang of it. It’s a tad bit tricky at first, but very doable.

The end result was that the kids loved these chocolate frogs, cards, and boxes. Give it a whirl! It’s cheaper than visiting the theme parks, but when you do, don’t forget that I have Universal Studios Hollywood discounts and Universal Orlando discounts!