cross
La Jolla Mom

Disneyland vs. Disney’s California Adventure: Pros and Cons

Written with significant help from a former cast member

BY La Jolla Mom
This site generates income via purchases made through links to carefully-curated travel and lifestyle brands.

Ideally, if you are visiting Disneyland Resort, you’d have at least two days to spend time in both of the parks. Otherwise, you need to know how to divide your time.

Disneyland has a lot in common with Disneyland Paris in that each park’s general layouts presented to guests is similar. But, if you have ever been to Disneyland Paris, you know that the second gate, Walt Disney Studios, doesn’t have a whole lot to offer.  

At Disneyland Resort, it’s not so simple. Disney’s California Adventure has come a long way in almost 20 years, and it continues to evolve more than any other Disney park. On the other hand, Disneyland is the original Disney theme park, and there is so much to discover, both old and new.

So, in the question of Disneyland vs. Disney’s California Adventure, who wins?

Pros and Cons of Disneyland vs. Disney’s California Adventure

Both parks have a long list of pros and the cons aren’t actually negatives. They’re meant to point out what one park has that the other doesn’t so that you can make decisions based on your interests.

Disneyland Pros

As the original Disney Park, Disneyland has a lot going for it. Fans of the Magic Kingdom at Walt Disney World Resort like to downplay the success of Disneyland and Walt Disney’s overall satisfaction with it. The truth is that most of Walt Disney’s disappointment with Disneyland was fixed by Michael Eisner’s approach to building a more immersive resort experience.

Disneyland characters in front of Sleeping Beauty's Castle
Photo courtesy of Disneyland Resort

Disneyland has nostalgia on its side, and not just because it’s older. It was created to evoke these euphoric feelings from the beginning. That’s part of its genius.

You also can’t argue the presence of Walt Disney at Disneyland. From the firehouse apartment to the Golden Horseshoe balcony to the espresso machine at Cafe Orleans, there are traces of him everywhere.

Even if you don’t have that same sort of reverence for the man who created Disneyland there is a certain charm to the place. The level of imagineering under Walt Disney’s guidance far surpassed what has been done since its creation. The use of space and visual trickery that Disney is known for were operating on a scale back then that has not been reached since.  

Take for example the difference between the crooked path of Adventureland and the wide open space of Frontierland. Magic Kingdom’s versions may be larger, but they pale in comparison in terms of craft and details.

Disney’s California Adventure Pros

Since 2001, Disney’s California Adventure has grown a lot. The park offered very little when it opened. However, even then, it was a remarkable tribute to the diversity of California. Some of it, such as Grizzly Peak, was stunning and still is.

Disney built on the California premise and refined it, bringing Walt Disney’s story front and center. One of the best aspects of Disney’s California Adventure is Buena Vista Street. The setting takes you to the beginning of Walt Disney’s California journey, starting with Oswald the Lucky Rabbit greeting guests at the entrance of the park. Buena Vista Street is a gorgeously aesthetic choice for the introduction to the park and a perfect mirror to Main Street, U.S.A. at Disneyland.

Disney’s California Adventure is not locked into a formula like Disneyland is. It’s a testing ground for new ideas and is afforded more leniency when it comes to change. Lands have come and gone in the park’s short history.  

One of the great advantages of visiting Disney’s California Adventure is Cars Land which pulls right into the world of Radiator Springs. The design is flawless and the views of Ornament Valley are breathtaking. Radiator Springs Racers is one of the best Disney rides, anywhere… ever.

A guide to visiting Disney California Adventure
Radiator Springs Racers – Paul Hiffmeyer/Disneyland Resort

Disneyland Cons

Disneyland’s “deficiencies” only lie in what is available elsewhere. You can’t meet Marvel characters in Disneyland. Certain attractions like Guardians of the Galaxy Mission: Break Out and Soarin’ Around the World are not at Disneyland.

Really, the only reason not to go to Disneyland is if you want to experience the attractions and experiences that are only available at Disney’s California Adventure.

Disney’s California Adventure Cons

Due to the experimental freedom and the constant change, Disney’s California Adventure has still not settled into a unified theme. It’s a collection of ideas at best. Many of those ideas are great, but they don’t have the timelessness or the consistency of Disneyland.

Pixar Pier is an attempt to unify an area of the park in a way that just pales in comparison to how cool Cars Land is. As Pixar Pier is newly-opened, the jury is still out but you can definitely find good casual eats there (see below).

Another potential down note for the park for some is the lack of any Lucasfilm presence. Disney’s California Adventure should have been the park of choice for Star Wars Land (Galaxy’s Edge) and it wasn’t. Although Imagineers chose a location for Galaxy’s Edge within Disneyland that makes thematic sense, it would have fit in much better if it was incorporated into Disney’s California Adventure in a similar fashion to Pixar and Marvel.

Dining at Disneyland Versus Disney California Adventure

We always look forward to eating at Disneyland Resort. From the Halloween and Christmas treats scattered throughout both resorts to old standby’s like Dole Whip, choices abound.

Disneyland Dining

When it comes to food, Disneyland has The Blue Bayou, a romantically-lit table service restaurant that overlooks the Pirates of the Caribbean from a beautifully designed terrace. Adventureland offers exotic quick service small plates at The Tropical Hideaway, where one can also source a famous Dole Whip.

The Tropical Hideaway at Disneyland Resort
Located on the Jungle River shores in Adventureland at Disneyland Park, The Tropical Hideaway is the destination for extraordinary worldly eats. Menu items include warm steamed bao buns, chilled ramen salad, Sweet Pineapple Lumpia, Dole Whip and more. Disneyland Park is located in Anaheim, Calif. (David Nguyen/Disneyland Resort)

The Hungry Bear offers views of Tom Sawyer Island and the Mark Twain. Carnation Cafe offers an atmospheric dining experience in the heart of Main Street U.S.A.

Disney California Adventure Dining

Disney’s California Adventure offers a lot of dining. Pixar Pier has tons of counter service options that pay homage to the films from Angry Dogs to Bing Bong’s Sweet Stuff. Lamplight Lounge here where Pixar Fans can go for a drink and some inspiration from the sketches and animated movie memorabilia.

Carthay Circle Theater is a beautifully decorated replica of the theater of the same name that premiered Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. This fine dining experience is superb, and even the lounge is such a sweet way to unwind at the end of a thrilling day.

Food and Wine Festival at Disney's California Adventure Park
Disney California Adventure Food and Wine Festival takes place March 1 to April 23, 2019. Guests can explore California-inspired cuisine and beverages, plus live entertainment, family-friendly seminars and cooking demonstrations. (Joshua Sudock/Disneyland Resort)

Disney’s California Adventure offers something else that Disneyland does not have: food festivals. During the Lunar New Year Celebration, Food and Wine Festival, or the Festival of the Holidays you must visit Disney’s California Adventure if you are a foodie.

Attractions at Disneyland vs Disney California Adventure

Which park you visit depends largely on which rides and attractions you’re interested in. Disneyland rides are entirely different from Disney’s California Adventure rides.

Disneyland Rides and Attractions

The Matterhorn at Disneyland Resort is a classic ride.
The Matterhorn is a classic Disneyland ride (Paul Hiffmeyer/Disneyland Resort)

Disneyland has many of the most popular Disney attractions. The Disney Mountain Range consisting of Space Mountain, Matterhorn, Big Thunder, and Splash Mountain all house popular rides.  

Disneyland also has the best rides for families including the entirety of Fantasyland with its princesses and rides that are popular with younger kids. In addition, the most classic Disney rides from Pirates of the Caribbean and The Haunted Mansion to The Jungle Cruise and The Tiki Room all await inside.

Disney’s California Adventure Rides and Attractions

Disney California Adventure: Grizzly River Run
Paul Hiffmeyer/Disneyland Resort

Disney’s California Adventure is the place to go for Pixar and Marvel experiences. Pixar Pier has the Incredicoaster and other themed attractions. Cars Land is home to Radiator Springs Racers, Hollywoodland has Guardians of the Galaxy. When Marvel Land opens, they’ll change the boundaries of these two lands. Yes, Disney’s California Adventure is getting a Marvel Land!

Buy Disneyland Discount Tickets to Both Parks

The good news is that visiting both parks is made easy with Disneyland discount tickets that can be one park per day tickets or Park Hopper tickets in increments of two, three, four or five days. 

The good news is that tickets of three days in length or longer are eligible for Magic Morning admission. Print and go straight to the gate or use a mobile ticket.

Shop Discount Disneyland Tickets

The Bottom Line

In the Battle of Disneyland vs. Disney’s California Adventure, especially with Galaxy’s Edge opening up this Summer, Disneyland is the clear winner for now. We’ll just have to see what Marvel Land brings for Disney’s California Adventure in the future.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.